Show notes
A secret kept for sixty years can weigh as much as the history behind it. The Optimist (2026) tells the true story of Herbert Heller, a Holocaust survivor who stayed silent for six decades about Terezín, Auschwitz and the escape he made as a boy, until a troubled teenager gave him a reason to speak.
Mike talks with writer-director Finn Taylor and star Stephen Lang about the new drama, which worked the festival circuit in 2024, played theaters in March and arrives on streaming November 17. Taylor traces the eight or nine years it took: producer Jeanine Thomas, a friend of Heller's, brought him the challenge of holding two stories at once, then flew him to Prague. He visited Auschwitz and Terezín and interviewed Heller and his family for years. The shoot took a crew of hundreds on two continents.
Lang, who never met Heller, explains the difference between playing a man he could see and hear in recordings and playing George Pickett, who left none. He set out to absorb Heller, not mimic him, and Taylor says the family was gobsmacked by the result. Lang also praises Elsie Fisher, his partner in a quiet, measured pairing of two careful characters carrying their own traumas, and Robin Weigert. Mike signs off by telling Lang he has been a fan since Manhunter (1986).
Follow The Optimist on Instagram (opens in a new tab) and visit the film's official website (opens in a new tab).
Transcript
An automatic transcript from Spreaker. It has not been proofread, so names, titles and spellings may be wrong, and it does not say who is speaking.
Show the transcript (about 1,800 words)
Hold your ears folks it's showtime people pay good money to see this movie when they go out to a theater they want cold sodas hot popcorn and no monsters in the projection. Booth everyone pretend podcasting isn't boring. Turn it off turn it off turn it off. Why me? Why you?
Yeah, why'd you pick me to tell your story to? Maybe it's because 60 years is a long time to hold on to a secret. My father gave us a magical childhood. How did you do it? Boys, calm down.
It's too beautiful to stay inside. He's opening up to you This is why they act as though nothing bad can happen. But it's not true. Don't stop recording. He's some old European guy.
What do I have in common with him? What a freak. We don't play with you. It was something, apparently. No, no, no, no.
I came face to face with Auschwitz. Death camp. Do you ever feel guilty for having made it? Perhaps. And now, I want to hear your story.
We've always felt different from other people. What are you supposed to do when you've done something unforgivable? What wrong did you do? I know it feels like it's the end of the world, but it's not. I saw the end of the world.
I had a ringside seat for you. When this war is over, we will be reunited. I felt guilty for decades. And then, I began to tell you my story. Whoa.
Tonight, my secret dance. And maybe yours could, too. Hey, folks. Welcome to The Projection Booth. I'm your host, Mike White.
On this episode, I am sitting down with Mr. Stephen Lang and writer-director Finn Taylor all about their new film, The Optimist. It is based on a true story of Herbert Heller, a Holocaust survivor who spent his life helping troubled teenagers heal. Mr. Taylor spent nearly a decade developing the script, and Mr.
Lang plays Heller alongside Elsie Fisher in a terrific supporting role. I had a great time talking with them. It's only a few minutes long. Didn't get too much screen time with those guys, but I hope you really enjoy this. Mr.
Taylor, I think I'll start with you, if that's all right. I'm very curious how this movie came to happen. Producer Janine Thomas was a friend of Herbert Heller's, and she approached me with an interesting challenge, screenwriting-wise, which was holding two stories simultaneously. You know, generally in movies, you have one protagonist going from A to B or multiple. But here it was really, you know, a teenager and this man who'd lived with a six-year secret helping each other on a path through healing and then recounting you know, this epic escape he had in his childhood.
So once there was, I thought it was an intriguing yet challenging idea. But once I met Herbert, I felt the weight of responsibility to tell this man's story because I thought it was so important and not yet explored in films that I know about. And Mr. Lang, have you played many real life characters before? I have.
I've played quite a few historical characters. And I've characters from history who are not so well known, but who in fact, you know, existed. So yeah, I've done, I've done it before. And I, and I have, every time you approach anything, you kind of have to rediscover it, reinvent it every time. And so I wouldn't say there's one way you go at a historical character.
However, I think they do carry a certain extra added responsibility to, to kind of get it, to get the essence right. You know, If you're going to kind of shape facts of one's, you really need to know the facts that you're shaping, it seems to me. There's a lot of really wonderful clay to work with when you're working with a character who actually did exist. Well, with some of the characters that you've played where maybe they've been passed away for many years, maybe even a century or more, That's got to be, I would think, a lot different than playing somebody more contemporary where you could actually have a conversation with them. Do you want to have that conversation?
That's interesting. I mean, what's the difference, a difference between playing Herbert Heller and playing George Pickett, for example? is that there are no films of George Pickett. There are no recordings of George Pickett. Whereas I can, you know, do as much research. I can hear Herbert.
I can see Herbert. And I did. And take advantage of that. I'd be foolish not to, it seems to me. Which is not to say that I'm trying in the end to mimic his voice or his look or anything.
I just, I want to absorb him and I want to be able to be the vessel that convey the spirit and the optimism of this wonderful man, who I never met. Finn did meet him, but I came, you know, by the time I came to the project, I believe Herbert had been passed away for a few years at that point. Yeah, he passed away within a year of us beginning to make the film. Oh, wow. But I got to interview him for years in his family, and he was a very impressive person.
Yeah. And Stephen was the exact right person to say, I should say, Herbert's family was gobsmacked by the accuracy of Stephen's portrayal. And I don't necessarily mean, like, mimicry. I mean capturing his essence and the soul that emanated from him. It was amazing.
Oh, boy. I think it's been eight or nine years. You know, it took quite a while to write the script. And Janine, Thomas, the producer, flew us to Prague. I went to Auschwitz.
I went to Terezin. And we just worked, you know... With films, and Stephen can probably say this, it's really all about if you don't have a good script, you're not going to have a good movie no matter who you hire, really. So Janine, to her credit, the proper time to get... It's kind of a complex and unusual structure, screenwriting-wise, though I hope it doesn't seem so in the film.
And making it flow and kind of trying to make it feel seamless. So that was the longest part. But then Once we knew we were shooting, things moved pretty quickly. It took a crew of hundreds on two continents to pull it off. But it was a worthwhile quest, I must say.
When did you actually shoot this? We shot it in 2022, I believe. We started the festival circuit in 2023. 2024. Actually, we were editing in 23.
We started the festival circuit in 2024. And then we had a short theatrical run in March. Coming out, streaming in November. So obviously, Mr. Lang is a critical part of this, but so much of this movie weighs on Elsie Fisher as well.
And I was curious, what was that relationship, Mr. Lang, with working with your fellow actors on this and making sure, you know, because you could probably blow anybody else out of the water if you wanted to with your acting prowess, but how is that kind of sharing the screen and what's that relationship like with these other actors? Yeah. Well, yeah, I have been on sets where I've wanted to blow some people out of the water with my acting. I will admit to that, you know.
Yeah, yeah. But certainly what's preferable is to just sort of enter into the warm embrace of a colleague who is just there for you. And acting with Elsie was just a really rewarding and an intimate experience, a very quiet and beautiful one and measured. too, because we're playing two very careful characters here, characters who have gone through their own terrible traumas and are dealing with them, you know? And so there was, I think that gave rise to both a lot of sympathy, a lot of support, and sometimes resistance in the characterizations, I think. She's just a marvelous character. professional, I think.
I think this film is cast beautifully aside from myself because the young fellow who plays me when I'm one is just, he's so right on. And then we had the beautiful Robin Wiegert in it as well. I mean, really, it was a good cast. Fantastic. Before we cut out, I just want to say, Mr.
Lang, I've been a fan of yours since Manhunter, so it's really an honor speaking with you. And then, Mr. Taylor, what a wonderful job. Where can people find this movie now and see it? It will be streaming November 17th everywhere.
Apple TV Prime, Fandango, YouTube. YouTube, everywhere, starting November 17th. You can pre-buy on Apple right now, today, if you want, which would be great. All right. Terrific.
Well, Mr. Lange, Mr. Taylor, thank you so much for your time today, gentlemen. I really appreciate it. Yeah.
Y'all have a good one. Bye-bye. Next time you're found with your chin on the ground, there's a lot to be learned. So look around. Just what makes that little old ant think he'll move that rubber tree plant?
Anyone knows an ant can't move a rubber tree plant. But he's got high hopes. He's got high hopes. I hope he's got my apple pie in the. I hope so Anytime you're getting low Instead of letting go Just remember that ant Oops, there goes another rubber tree.
Plant Oops, there goes another rubber tree plant Oops, there goes another rubber tree plant When troubles call And your back's to the wall There's a lot to be learned That one could. Fall Once there was a silly old ram Thought he'd punch a hole in a dam No one could make that ram scram He kept butting that dam Cause he had. High hopes He had high hopes He had high apple pie. In the. I hope so Anytime you're feeling bad Instead of feeling sad Just remember that ram Oops, there goes a billion kilowatt.
Dam Oops, there goes. A billion kilowatt dam Oops. There goes a billion kilowatt dam Bye. Bye. Bye.
Comments
No comments yet.